The Discord server security score
EvaluBot scores every Discord server out of 100. Each audit starts at 100 and loses points only for 13 specific, fixable issues, such as 2FA not being required for moderators or @everyone holding a dangerous permission. Grades run from Excellent at 90 and above to At risk below 40, and the report explains every point.
What would your server score?
Answer 14 questions about your server's settings. The estimate uses the same points and caps as a real audit, and moves as you go.
Is 2FA required for moderator actions?
Server Settings > Safety Setup. Only the server owner can change it.
Not required: -20, critical
What is the verification level?
Server Settings > Safety Setup > Verification Level.
None: -6, medium
Does @everyone hold a takeover permission?
Administrator, Manage Server, Manage Roles, Manage Channels, Manage Webhooks, Kick Members, Ban Members or Timeout Members.
Yes: -20, critical
How many elevated permissions does @everyone hold?
Manage Expressions, Manage Nicknames, Manage Messages, Manage Threads and Posts, Manage Events, Mute, Deafen or Move Members, View Audit Log, View Server Insights, Priority Speaker or Bypass Slowmode.
-4 each, up to -12, high
Can @everyone mention @everyone, @here and all roles?
Server Settings > Roles > @everyone > Mention @everyone, @here, and All Roles.
Yes: -15, critical
How many roles have Administrator?
Bot roles count; leave out EvaluBot's own. Up to 2 is free, and each role beyond that is one more path to a full takeover.
-4 for each beyond 2, up to -16, high
Does a role members get on their own have Administrator?
Roles people get by boosting, buying a server subscription, a Linked Role, or through a Twitch or YouTube integration.
Yes: -20, critical
How many of those roles hold a staff permission?
Manage Server, Manage Roles, Manage Channels, Manage Webhooks, Ban, Kick, Timeout Members or Mention @everyone.
-5 per role, up to -15, high
How many other roles hold Manage Server, Roles, Channels or Webhooks?
Leave out roles with Administrator, bot and integration roles, the roles anyone can get, and @everyone.
-5 per role, up to -15, high
Does a role with Manage Roles sit above a role with Administrator?
Its members can then give themselves Administrator, since Discord lets them hand out any role below their own.
Yes: -10, critical
Can @everyone control a channel?
In any channel, an override for @everyone allows Manage Channel, Manage Permissions, Manage Webhooks or Mention @everyone.
Yes: -15 (once, however many channels), critical
In how many other channels does @everyone have moderator powers?
An override for @everyone allows Manage Messages, Manage Threads and Posts, Manage Events, Mute, Deafen or Move Members, or Priority Speaker.
-4 per channel, up to -12, high
Can @everyone open threads in a channel they cannot post in?
A text or announcement channel @everyone can see but not send messages in, while it can still Create Public Threads.
Yes: -10, high
How many webhooks does the server have?
Server Settings > Integrations > Webhooks.
More than 15: -5, low
Estimated score
Excellent
All 13 checks pass.
An estimate from the 13 checks EvaluBot scores, assuming a full audit where every section could be read. Your real score comes from /audit, which reads the actual settings, including every channel override, so it can differ.
Exactly what costs points.
Points come off only for these. The score is clamped between 0 and 100.
| Check | Section | Severity | Points |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2FA is not required for moderator actions | Server | critical | -20 |
| @everyone holds a takeover permission, such as Administrator, Manage Roles or Ban Members | Roles | critical | -20 |
| @everyone can mention @everyone, @here and all roles | Roles | critical | -15 |
| A role members get by boosting, a server subscription, Linked Roles or an integration holds Administrator or a staff permission | Roles | critical | -20 with Administrator, otherwise -5 per role, up to -15 |
| A role with Manage Roles sits above a role with Administrator | Roles | critical | -10 |
| An override for @everyone lets every member manage a channel or its permissions, create webhooks or ping everyone | Channels | critical | -15 |
| More than 2 roles grant Administrator, bot roles included | Roles | high | -4 per extra role, up to -16 |
| Roles that are not admin, bot or integration roles hold Manage Server, Manage Roles, Manage Channels or Manage Webhooks | Roles | high | -5 per role, up to -15 |
| @everyone holds an elevated permission, such as Manage Messages or View Audit Log | Roles | high | -4 each, up to -12 |
| An override for @everyone gives every member moderator powers in a channel | Channels | high | -4 per channel, up to -12 |
| A channel has a thread-permission gap | Channels | high | -10 |
| Verification level is None | Server | medium | -6 |
| More than 15 webhooks | Webhooks | low | -5 |
A takeover permission is Administrator, Manage Server, Manage Roles, Manage Channels, Manage Webhooks, Kick Members, Ban Members or Timeout Members. What each one can do
Five grades, from Excellent to At risk.
The grade sits beside the score in the report's ring gauge, so you can tell at a glance where the server stands.
- Excellent90 to 100
- Good75 to 89
- Fair60 to 74
- Needs work40 to 59
- At riskBelow 40
Rules that keep it fair
- Only the sections in the audit are scored. A partial audit scores just its sections, and the report says which ones.
- A section EvaluBot could not read, because a permission is missing, is listed as not assessed and never costs points. The same goes for channels hidden from EvaluBot.
- Nothing is counted twice: a role anyone can get is scored only by its own check, and a channel that gives everyone control is not also counted for moderator powers.
- On Premium, a risk the server accepted with /auditfix accept costs no points. The report still lists it, with the reason and what it would cost.
- Every deduction is listed with its point cost, severity and how to fix it.
Deliberately not scored
- Routine moderation permissions on staff roles: Manage Messages, Timeout, Mute, Move and Kick
- Webhook counts of 15 or fewer
- The size of the ban list
- Everything in the recommendations list
Advice that does not touch the score.
Every report ends with recommendations, each written as a problem and a fix. They are advisory, and their count is the audit's issues found.
Critical
- 2FA is not required for moderators
- @everyone holds a takeover permission
- @everyone can mention @everyone
- An override for @everyone lets every member control a channel
- Anyone can get Administrator by boosting, paying, linking an account or through an integration
- A role with Manage Roles can hand its members Administrator
- Default notifications are All Messages on a server with 1,000 or more members
General
- @everyone holds an elevated permission, or has moderator powers in a channel
- Anyone can get staff permissions by boosting, paying, linking an account or through an integration
- A webhook was made by someone no longer in the server
- The server is listed in Server Discovery with verification Low or None
- A bot Discord has not verified holds Administrator or staff permissions, or any bot has Administrator
- Discord detected a raid or DM spam in the last 7 days, or a Community server has Activity Alerts off
- Everyone can see a channel inside a private category, or a member's own override gives them control of a channel
- A role anyone can get by boosting, paying, linking an account or through an integration lets its members see a private channel
- AutoMod is not set up, its spam rules are off, or a rule sends alerts to a deleted channel
- The media content filter is off
- Any role has Administrator, so review who holds it
- Discord's risky @everyone defaults are on: Create Expressions, Use External Apps, Create Events, Create Public Threads, Send Text-to-Speech Messages, Use External Sounds, Set Voice Channel Status
- Roles hold sensitive permissions
- A channel has a thread-permission gap
Optional
- The server widget is on, the server has a template link, or Rules Screening is off on a Community server
- Default notifications are All Messages on a server under 1,000 members
- Community is off, or onboarding is not set up
- The server or Community profile description is missing
- Channels with no messages in 90+ days
- Roles with fewer than 3 human members
- Webhooks could not be read, or there are more than 15
- The ban list could not be read, or holds more than 100 bans
- An AutoMod rule is off, mention raid protection is off, or AutoMod rules could not be read
23 sensitive permissions, traced to every role.
The Roles section maps each of these to every role that holds it, with member counts and who last changed each privileged role. Legitimate staff roles hold some of them, so a role on the list is a prompt to review, not a verdict. Administrator gets its own list.
- Manage Channels
- Manage Roles
- Manage Expressions
- Create Expressions
- View Audit Log
- Manage Webhooks
- View Server Insights
- Manage Server
- Manage Nicknames
- Kick Members
- Ban Members
- Timeout Members
- Mention @everyone, @here and All Roles
- Manage Messages
- Manage Threads and Posts
- Mute Members
- Deafen Members
- Move Members
- Priority Speaker
- Use External Apps
- Create Events
- Manage Events
- Pin Messages
Questions about the score
What is a good Discord server security score?
75 or above is Good and 90 or above is Excellent. 60 to 74 is Fair, 40 to 59 Needs work, and below 40 is At risk. A score of 100 means none of the 13 scored checks found a problem.
How is the EvaluBot security score calculated?
Every audit starts at 100 and loses points only for 13 specific, fixable issues, from 2FA not being required for moderators (20 points) to more than 15 webhooks (5 points). The score is clamped between 0 and 100, and the report lists every deduction with its cost, severity and how to fix it.
Do recommendations affect the score?
No. Recommendations, grouped Critical, General and Optional, are advisory. The report says so, and only the 13 scored checks cost points. The number of recommendations is the audit's issues found count.
Does a missing bot permission lower my score?
Never. A section EvaluBot could not read is marked not assessed and costs no points. Only the sections in the audit are scored, so a partial audit scores just its sections.
Why are moderation permissions on staff roles not scored?
Staff roles legitimately need permissions like Manage Messages, Timeout, Mute, Move and Kick, so holding them costs nothing. EvaluBot still lists every role that holds one of 23 sensitive permissions, as a prompt to review.
How accurate is the score calculator?
It uses the same 13 checks, points and caps as a real audit, assuming every section could be read. It relies on your answers, while /audit reads the real settings, including every channel's permission overrides.
How do I raise my score quickly?
Start with the deductions the Audit complete message lists: the three that cost the most, each with the step that clears it. On Premium, /auditfix plan checks the server as it stands now and lists everything that costs points, costliest first, ticking items off as you fix them, without using an audit. A risk you keep on purpose can be accepted with a reason, so it stops costing points but stays in every report.
Get your real score.
The calculator estimates. /audit reads every role, channel and override, and explains every point. Read-only from start to finish.
Join the Discord servers already running EvaluBot.
Running a busy server? Premium gives it 15 audits a month, every risky change as an alert, fix plans and more. See Premium